Main Theme / Objective
Using Litigation, Research and Advocacy to challenge unlawful raids in the homes of Johannesburg inner-city residents. On the basis of previous SERI research in the inner city and litigation, we engaged in media advocacy and communication to ensure the profile of the case was raised and maintained in the print, radio and television and social media.
Beneficiary Groups
Residents of 11 inner city buildings in Johannesburg
Location (Community / City)
Province / State
Country
Participating Population
The inner city is home to hundreds of thousands of low-income residents. The raids affected 11 buildings in the Johannesburg inner city
Practice Description
Brief quantitative and qualitative description
SERI used a combination of litigation and advocacy to successfully challenge the constitutionality of the raids and October 2021, the Constitutional Court confirmed an earlier judgment by the Johannesburg High Court preventing warrantless searches and allowing inner city occupiers to enjoy their homes without fear of being raided by the police. Our Advocacy work was instrumental in revealing the realities faced by poor people, allowing official legal and policy response to those realities to be critiqued, and protecting people against violations of their rights. This, in turn, also empowered residents with the tools and information necessary to exercise their rights.
Habitat & Human Rights Relevance
This practice ensures that the government is better-informed of the realities facing the poor and further compelled to act. Furthermore, the poor are empowered to articulate and assert their own rights claims. Without both of these things happening, human rights cannot be enforced.
HIC Thematic Areas Related to This Practice
How this practice relate to HIC thematic areas?
This links directly to the theme of Housing and land rights ensuring that inner city occupiers enjoy their homes without fear of being raided by the police. In its ruling, the Constitutional Court found that far from being a way of restoring public order, the raids were conducted with an ulterior purpose to frighten and harass the applicants into leaving their homes.
Context & approach: what challenge did it address and how?
The inner city is home to hundreds of thousands of low-income residents. Due
to the perception of “crime and grime”, the inner city is frequently subjected to “urban regeneration efforts” to attract investment which often translate into rights violations and harassment of inner city residents. Between June 2017 and May 2018, 11 buildings in Johannesburg’s central business district were raided at the behest of the then-minister of police, Fikile Mbalula, and the former mayor of Johannesburg, Herman Mashaba. The raids were championed as part of a socalled urban renewal initiative to bring back “law and order” in Johannesburg. Collectively, the buildings were raided more than 20 times, with some being raided as many as five times in 10 months.
Without SERI’s intervention, the raids would likely have persisted.
Key Outcomes & lessons Learned
On 22 October 2021, the Constitutional Court confirmed an earlier judgment by the Johannesburg High Court declaring section 13(7)(c) of the SAPS Act constitutionally invalid insofar as it allows for warrantless searches.
SERI also led an active social media campaign coupled with a media advocacy campaign.
Lessons learned include that the use of research, advocacy and litigation can be a powerful combination for influencing change.