The current global discourse on
sustainability of our habitat, and the need for “Sustainable Development Goals”
(SDGs) in order to save the planet, has a significant resonance with the idea
of the kind of city we should and can build, and what we simply cannot afford
to build in the interest of our collective future. The proposed SDGs
2015, reserves Goal 11 for cities of the world, stating: Make cities and human
settlements inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable. However, India’s
position on this stand-alone Goal 11 has been dwindling, from a complete opposition
to a more recent cautious support of the goal.
There has been on-going discussions and controversies in the formulation of the
SDGs. There are gaps, and doubts, regarding what they can really achieve given
the record of the earlier Millennium Development Goals or MDGs, which
aimed to ‘end poverty’. SDGs are far more comprehensive, and global civil
society has engaged in the framing of the Goals far more than it has in the
MDGs. Within global civil society, even from those organisations which have
been part of the Open Working Groups of UN member states to discuss and fine
tune the targets, there has been discomfort with some limitations in the Goals
per se. For instance, there is a suggestion to add ‘productive’ (i.e.
inclusive, safe, resilient, productive and sustainable) to Goal 11 in order to
include and indeed emphasize economic activity and livelihood needs of the poor
in the city. Besides the entire discourse of identifying the root causes
of poverty and inequality and the means to address these are naturally the core
issues for civil society in general and peoples movements in particular. .
After adoption of the SDGs 2015, in December 2015 in New York, the Habitat III
conference (November 2016) in Quito, Ecuador, will be the first global summit
to adopt the post-2015 agenda and is expected to bring together a diverse group
of stakeholders to discuss housing and habitat solutions and Goal 11.
Besides this, the meeting of the Conference of parties or COP 21 which is
organised annually by the UNFCC will see heated discussions and controversies
on the harmful effects of climate change, carbon emission, and the development
paradigm, all of which have direct bearing on urban development and planning
and the kind of cities we should build.
In India, the discourse on what constitutes a sustainable city has been ongoing
at various levels and from diverse viewpoints. But there is a gap in terms
of serious and sustained discussion within civil society and between
civil society and policy makers, including government. It is a moot point
as to whether there is discussion within the various wings of government also
on these issues in order to formulate policies which are in tune with SDGs, to
which the government is supposed to be committed.
Meanwhile, a national level the flagship programme of Smart Cities, has been
launched by the Govt. of India. It has as its declared aims, the
responsibility of ensuring socio-economic upliftment by promoting business
opportunities, ensuring citizens’ participation and improving e-governance for
better service delivery. Given such an ambitious sounding urban development
programme in which vast amounts of money will be spent, it becomes
essential to engage within people’s groups/constituencies to imagine their own
vision and to make sure that it is their ideas and demands that go into the
planning of their city. It is the need of the hour to act together, to
put forward a framework in order to engage with and understand the significance
and content of the SDGs and the Habitat II discourse; to debate and inform the
making of Smart Cities; to decide what kind of cities we want, and provide
concrete alternatives, to struggle to ensure that our cities are “inclusive,
safe, resilient, and sustainable”, and be truly equitable and productive.
We take this opportunity to invite you for a 3 day programme “Civil Society
Convention on Sustainable Cities” to be held in Mumbai fromOctober
15th to 17th, 2015.
The convention will try and discuss many of the critical questions relating to
our cities; questions related to habitat and livelihood, socio-cultural
exclusion, climate justice and role of people’s participation in planning for
sustainable cities.
We hope you will be able to join us for this and provide your valuable insights
to the discussion. We wish this to be a truly interactive convention
where there will be interaction and discussion to clarify issues.
Meena R Menon (CiRiC, ActionAid India), T Jayaraman (Tata Institute of Social
Sciences), Prasad Shetty (School of Environment and Architecture)
* Click here to download the program.