What: Press conference exposing how Private Investment firms are buying up thousands of units of formerly city and state subsidized housing at inflated prices and placing tenants at risk. In some cases, deals are backed by Wall Street firms who are using investments made city and state pension funds.
Where: The entrance to 3333 Broadway,
When: Thursday September 20th, 10:00 AM
Who: [Bill Thompson, Tom DiNapoli] 3333 Residents Association, NY State Tenants and Neighbors, Urban Homesteading Assistance Board, P.I.E Campaign, Association for Housing and Neighborhood Development
The international investment group, Cammebys International, headed by NY real-estate mogul, Rubin Schron has acquired and deregulated at least 10 former Mitchell-Lama developments in four boroughs over the last several years. Recently Cammebys sold five former Mitchell-Lamas developments, serving almost 4000 families in Harlem and
Public records show that Morgan Stanley Real-Estate Fund IV and the City Investment Fund receives more than $158 million from the New York City Employees Retirement System (NYCERS) and the New York State and Local Retirement System (NYSLRS), which represent over 1.3 million employees and pensioners. Neither the City nor the State Comptrollers were aware that they were investments were aiding speculative real-estate deals targeting formerly subsidized housing. Quote from DiNapoli or Thompson
The sale raises serious questions about the underwriting assumptions and long term projections these private equity groups are using when making decisions about acquisition of formerly subsidized real-estate. The sale to Putnam was finance by an $800 Million loan, which translates into $1200 pre unit in new debt service. Subsequently, there is now tremendous pressure on Putnam to get rid of existing low and moderate income tenants and replace them with residents who can pay substantially higher rents.
NY State Tenants & Neighbors and the Urban Homesteading Assistance Board, tenants and other housing advocates are calling on the city and state regulatory agencies to recognize this new threat facing Mitchell-Lama and former Mitchell-Lama tenants, and to work with the affordable housing community to identify new solutions to protect the affordable housing stock from predatory and/or speculative buy-outs.


Click here to download the chart “Tracking the sales of five former Mitchell-Lamas in Manhattan & Roosevelt Island: Metro North, Riverside Park Community, Schomburg Plaza, Eastwood and the UPACAs” compiled by the Urban Homesteading Assistance Board and Tenants & Neighbors, September 2007.
NY pension funds investing in private equity deals that prey on affordable housing. The chart shows the connections between the buyers of a 4000 unit portfolio and the pension funds. our press release and a short article from the NY Daily News. We dont have print copies of the other stories, but here are links to them online:

source: NAHT